It's Not Fair

| 1 Comment | 0 TrackBacks

For my graduation from seminary, I bought myself a tablet computer for use in worship. I used it the next day, and it worked fine.

Since then, my favorite online discount site has offered the same tablet for substantially less.

It's not fair!

I'm hearing the fairness issue brought up in terms of immigration, that having a path to citizenship for undocumented persons is unfair to those who have gone through the existing procedure.

We often judge fairness comparatively, but is that the best way to think of it? What constitutes fair?

In the case of my tablet computer: if I thought this was not a fair price, I should not have purchased it. Finding it later for a lower price does not change the fairness of the price I paid.

And immigration reform doesn't change the fairness of the existing system. If the existing system is unfair in light of the reform, then it is also unfair now. 

Illegal immigrants from high-volume countries like Mexico are especially hit by the "line" -- USCIS is only now processing applications from 1993. -

Fixing a broken system isn't unfair to those who successfully navigated a broken system - the broken system itself is unfair. And the only way to stop being unfair is to fix the system.

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL:

1 Comment


Leave a comment

Recent Entries

Who Do You Think You Are? (Sermon)
Preached August 24, 2014 at St. Michaels UCC West Chicago ILYear A, eleventh Sunday after PentecostReadings:Romans 12:1-8Matthew 16:13-20More than a…
Jesus Gets It Wrong? (Sermon)
Preached August 17, 2014 at St. Michaels UCC West Chicago ILYear A, tenth Sunday after PentecostReadings:Isaiah 56:1, 6-8 (NRSV)Matthew…
Children, Dogs, and Mental Illness
This week, the Revised Common Lectionary - used by many churches to determine the readings for Sunday - calls for…

Twitter Updates

    Follow me on Twitter

    Facebook Updates



    Faith and Society


    LGBT and allies